The bottom line:
what has overthrowing the Haitian government accomplished?
Haiti might have to postpone elections in two months' time because it is ill-prepared, according to a new report. Brussels-based think tank International Crisis Group (ICG) says only a fifth of Haitians have registered to vote and the process is due to end next week. Local and municipal elections are planned for October with parliamentary and presidential elections in November. ... "Empty elections that produce a government with little legitimacy could drive Haiti into permanent failed state status, run by drug and criminal networks," said Mark L Schneider, Crisis Group's Senior Vice President.
So, we will have helped Haiti transition from being a desperately poor country with a small drug trafficking problem and scattered violence but an elected government to a desperately poor country with a major drug trafficking problem and widespread violence and the only popular party banned from elections, such that 80% of the people refuse to participate.
But the US is not alone in this. Haiti is Brazil's Iraq... and Canada's...and France's. France and, to a lesser degree, Canada, claimed to be acting from principles in refusing to endorse the invasion of Iraq, and they look doubly hypocritical over having participated in the Haitian occupation.
But the saddest case of all is Brazil. For perhaps the first time ever, they have a government that claims to represent ordinary people instead of the Brazilian oligarchy. They seen the US intervene again and again in Latin America. Have those interventions accomplished anything? Why are they joining in doing the same wrongs to people even weaker than themselves?
# posted by
Charles @ 8/04/2005 10:08:00 AM